25+ Best Bakeries in Brooklyn
Bakeries in Brooklyn are no joke. From old-school generational Italian bakeries, French bakeries, fusion bakeries to little shops just selling sweet treats and delicious fresh baked bread, our borough is LOADED!
In fact, Brooklyn is a powerhouse for baked goods and bread. From sugar-filled treats to savory loaves of lard bread, the bakeries in Brooklyn are some of the most famous in the world. After all, this is where the famous Brooklyn Blackout Cake originated! This popular dessert combines layers of chocolate pudding, frosting, and cake crumbles to create a delicious dessert.
Brooklyn is also home to the famous Ebinger’s Bakery, which closed down in 1972. Although this is originally where the blackout cake came from, many bakeries in Brooklyn have followed in their footsteps and created their own recipes.
A fun fact about this bakery in Brooklyn, Ebinger’s created the Brooklyn Blackout Cake in recognition of the mandatory blackout drills to protect Navy Yard from enemy planes during World War II which employed over 40,000 workers.
Needless to say, the cake was popularized and stuck around even after the war.
Below are the 25 best bakeries in Brooklyn mixing in the old-school family-run mom and pop shops to the new kids in town shaking things up with their legendary treats and bread.
Whether you’re craving a retro scene or an OG must-see, these bakeries all offer something that you won’t be able to find anywhere else!
Brooklyn Bakeries You Have to Try
Saraghina Bakery
View this post on Instagram
433 Halsey St, Bed-Stuy
Saraghina Bakery is a bakery in Brooklyn in Stuyvesant Heights that has been around since 2014. This is one of the best Brooklyn bakeries for those who want simple ingredients.
Known for its simple bread, Italian desserts, and fresh pasta, this bakery truly has it all. With all organic and natural ingredients, Saraghina Bakery is a great one-stop-shop for anyone that wants to make a dish by themselves at home!
Unlike other bakeries in Brooklyn that specialize in desserts and pastries, Saraghina Bakery has it all. If you make your way to this spot, you’ll be able to find pasta, eggs, cheeses, cooking oils, pizzas, and pre-made desserts! This is the best bakery in Brooklyn to visit if you want baking ingredients to take home.
Must-Try: loaves like ciabatta, focaccia, or their baguettes
Ladybird Bakery
View this post on Instagram
1112 8th Ave, Park Slope
Located in Park Slope in Brooklyn, Ladybird Bakery is a popular neighborhood shop that’s been around for over 20 years! This is one of the best Brooklyn bakeries for those who love traditional American desserts.
Formerly known as Two Little Red Hens, Ladybird Bakery is known for its American desserts. Their most popular dish is their famous red velvet cupcake. Visitors also visit this bakery for their well-known scones and pastries.
Ladybird Bakery is a great place to go if you’re looking for a celebration cake! At this spot, you’ll be able to find specialty cakes, cupcakes, pies, tarts, and more.
You can also get custom desserts made for any occasion! This is the best bakery in Brooklyn to get custom and traditional American desserts for larger groups!
Must-Try: red velvet cake or cupcake as well as a gorgeously decorated cake for any special occasion or celebration.
Brooklyn Artisan Bakehouse
View this post on Instagram
529 East New York Ave, Prospect Lefferts Gardens & 1371 Coney Island Ave, Midwood
Brooklyn Artisan Bakehouse is a bakehouse & cafe with locations in Prospect Lefferts Gardens and Midwood. This bakery is known for its outstanding loaves of bread. Whether you want ciabatta, sourdough, or a pack of pretzel buns, this is the best bakery in Brooklyn to find it!
Although The Brooklyn Artisan Bakehouse is a great place for treats and cooking essentials, it’s also a great cafe and restaurant to host events or grab a cup of coffee. During the day, this bakery serves coffee, salads, breakfast, and more!
Must-Try: loaves of their bread!
Mazzola Bakery
View this post on Instagram
529 Henry St, Cobble Hill
Located in Cobble Hill, Mazzola Bakery is a neighborhood bakeshop that’s known for its lard bread and Italian cookies. One of the best Brooklyn bakeries for those who crave Italian dishes, this Italian bakery has been using the same lard bread recipe for over 90 years, making it one of the best bakeries in Brooklyn to enjoy this special bread.
In fact, their recipe is specially homemade and includes genoa salami, provolone cheese, and black pepper. We love bringing it home and warming it back up.
That being said, Mazzola Bakery’s vast menu includes many other handmade breads and pastries, including cranberry walnut artisan bread, salt & cinnamon pretzel bagels, and espresso. This is one of the best to-go brunch spots in Carroll Gardens. Be sure to grab some carbs and coffee then head over a few blocks to either Carroll Park or Cobble Hill Park to enjoy your fresh-baked goodies.
During Easter, they sell the traditional Italian egg bread loaves that have hardboiled eggs braided into the Easter bread.
Must-Try: A loaf of the lard bread is a MUST!
Bushwick Bakery
View this post on Instagram
127 Central Ave, Bushwick
Bushwick Bakery is a bakery that’s been a local favorite since the spring of 1987. This is one of the best Brooklyn bakeries to get French bread and pastries. In fact, their cooking essentials and baked goods are so popular that they provide multiple ingredients for restaurants and grocery stores in the neighborhood!
If you make your way to Bushwick Bakery, you can expect to find a large menu that’s great for breakfast and lunch. Their most popular items include their cold sandwiches and seasonal lattes.
Although this bakery is a great place to grab a bite to eat, it’s also a great place to get custom desserts made! Whether you want a wedding cake or birthday desserts, Bushwick Bakery can take your special order and make your vision come to life.
Must-Try: One of their delectable pastries!
Four & Twenty Blackbirds
439 3rd Ave, Gowanus & 634 Dean St, Prospect Heights
Four & Twenty Blackbirds is a legendary pie shop located in Gowanus in Brooklyn run by two sisters who have a deep appreciation for traditional pies with a twist.
Their famous pie flavors include matcha custard, salted caramel apple, and lavender honey. Whether you want a slice or an entire pie for a celebration, this is one of the best Brooklyn bakeries to visit!
Founded in 2009, this bakery is also known for its unique baked pies and around the holidays you’ll want to be sure to order in advance. This is the best bakery in Brooklyn to get pie, whether you’re craving an entire pie or just a slice!
Must-Try: Salted Caramel Apple pie
Peter Pan Donuts & Pastry Shop
727 Manhattan Ave, Greenpoint
Peter Pan Donuts is a donut & pastry shop in Greenpoint, Brooklyn that has been baking fresh donuts daily for over 70 years! They are often dubbed as the best donuts in Brooklyn, and we have to agree.
They’re also known for their coffee, sandwiches, and ice cream. Many overnight workers in the local area love this donut shop since its doors open at 4:30 AM and close at 8 PM!
Must-Try: sour cream glazed donut, red velvet cake donut, and sourdough donut
Bakeri
View this post on Instagram
105 Freeman St, Greenpoint & 150 Wythe Ave, Williamsburg
Bakeri is a popular bakery in Brooklyn with two locations, one in Williamsburg and the other in Greenpoint. This Brooklyn bakery offers bread, cakes, and pies.
Whether you’re in the mood for a fresh loaf of sourdough or a German chocolate cake, Bakeri is sure to have something that will cure your cravings and is a popular lunch spot since they have great sandwiches.
Although there is often a long line at this bakery in the mornings, it’s a great place to stop at if you’re looking for a quick breakfast sandwich, coffee, or dessert!
Must-Try: sourdough rye and German chocolate cake
Ostrovitsky Bakery
View this post on Instagram
1124 Avenue J, Midwood
Ostrovitsky Bakery is a traditional kosher bakery located in West Midwood, Brooklyn. This family-owned bakery in Brooklyn is known for its premium chocolate desserts, including its chocolate babka cupcakes, chocolate danishes, and rum balls.
This bakery is a great place to go if you need baked goods for a gift or celebration! They offer gift boxes and gifts that are great for special events.
Must-Try: chocolate babka and pull away challah bread
Betty Bakery
View this post on Instagram
448 Atlantic Ave, Boerum Hill & 211 Prospect Park West, Windsor Terrace
Betty Bakery is a retro bakery located in Boerum Hill and a location now in Windsor Terrace. This bakery in Brooklyn is known for its gourmet twinkies and cakes that are customizable for special occasions!
If you make your way to Betty Bakery, expect a colorful aesthetic and a wide range of unique cupcake flavors to choose from. Keep in mind that this special, veteran-led bakery offers outdoor seating only and a credit card minimum of $15!
Must-Try: funfetti twinkie or any of their specialty cakes
Runner & Stone
View this post on Instagram
285 3rd Ave, Gowanus
Runner & Stone is an American restaurant that functions more like a high-end bakery during the day and a favorite dinner spot by night.
This restaurant/bakery in Brooklyn is located in Gowanusand is known for its house-made bread and pastries. They also offer American-style dishes and cocktails, making it a great place for a larger meal!
Founded in 2012, Runner & Stone is much more than just a bakery. This all-in-one shop also functions as a restaurant, retail bakery, and bar! Their most popular items include seasonal salad, soups, and sandwiches.
A fun fact, this location is actually near the first tidewater grist mill in NYC!
Must-Try: chocolate almond croissant & baguettes!
Nuccio’s Bakery
View this post on Instagram
261 Avenue U, Gravesend
Nuccio’s Bakery in Gravesend is a neighborhood traditional Sicilian bakery in Brooklyn that serves homemade bread, cookies, and custom cakes!
This Italian bakery is extra popular during the holiday season since it offers a family Christmas breakfast that customers can pre-order ahead of time.
They’re also known for their Italian cookies, cannoli, and excellent lard bread. Keep in mind that Nuccio’s Bakery only takes cash.
Must-Try: shortcake cookies and cannoli!
Fortunato Brothers
View this post on Instagram
289 Manhattan Ave, East Williamsburg
Fortunato Brothers is a family-run pastry shop and one of the best bakeries in Brooklyn that is located in East Williamsburg that’s a classic Italian bakeshop since 1976.
This famous old-school bakery in Brooklyn is known for its Italian sweets from gelato to custom cakes and pastries! They carry a rarity in the city, Italian cheesecake that’s made with ricotta cheese rather than cream cheese that is heavenly.
They also are a popular spot to grab a coffee in the morning and extensive outdoor seating that’s great for those who want to stay awhile.
They have hyper-realistic-looking marzipan from gherkins to bananas and other fruits and vegetables.
Must-Try: Italian cream cheese, Italian cookies, and gelato
Leske’s Bakery
View this post on Instagram
7612 5th Ave, Bay Ridge
Leske’s Bakery in Bay Ridge is one of the bakeries in Brooklyn that’s known for its iconic black & white cookies and fresh bread! Locals particularly love Leske’s Bakery because they can get fresh bread or rolls delivered on almost any day.
Whether you’re in the mood for a dozen donuts or a cheese danish, this neighborhood staple is a well-stocked place that you can always count on. Customers love pairing their croissants and other desserts with their delicious coffee!
Must-Try: Black & White cookie & donuts
Baked
View this post on Instagram
359 Van Brunt St, Red Hook
Baked in Red Hook is one of the best bakeries in Brooklyn for brownies, cakes, cookies, and a wide range of breakfast pastries. With affordable pricing and desserts for almost any occasion, but Baked also has a famous cookbook.
They are most famous for their brownies and even have a global presence with a bakery location in Tokyo. While they started with the brownie, they have an array of delicious sweets to choose from including their specialty cakes and blondie bars.
Baked also offers online and in-person baking classes for customers that want to learn how to make their own culinary creations!
If you’d prefer to purchase one on your own, Baked has many creative and customizable desserts that are great for any occasion.
Must-Try: brownies or a slice of cake (or a whole one, or two)
Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery
View this post on Instagram
139 Smith St, Boerum Hill
Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery is a cozy spot located in Boerum Hill. They also have a Manhattan location in Times Square.
This best bakery in Brooklyn offers many desserts, delicious coffee, and a large outdoor patio that guests love. They also offer catering services and custom desserts that are great for any event.
Whether you’re craving a cup of coffee or a slice of oreo cheesecake, Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery has got you covered. Their slices of cake are legendary as well as their croissant donuts. Their portions are large, just the way we like our sweets.
Must-Try: slice of their rainbow cake or croissant donut
Bien Cuit
View this post on Instagram
120 Smith St, Boerum Hill & 721 Franklin Ave, Crown Heights
Bien Cuit is a French Brooklyn bakery that has two locations: one in Boerum Hill and one in Crown Heights. Bien Cuit means “well done” in French, which suits this bakery well since it’s known for its French bread and unique approach to baking.
Their bread is so popular that they ship nationwide! Their most popular bread includes their super crusty french baguettes, sunflower rye, and multigrain. Also, their croissants!
However, this artisanal bakery in Brooklyn has much more to offer. Guests also love their croissants, danishes, and pound cake! You can also come here to grab a sandwich for lunch if you want a larger meal.
Must-Try: fresh baguette and croissants
Ovenly
View this post on Instagram
210 Flatbush Ave, Park Slope, 31 Greenpoint Ave, Greenpoint, & 43 N 5th St, Williamsburg
Looking for the best bakery in Brooklyn for blackout cake? This is one of them with locations in Greenpoint, Williamsburg, and Park Slope.
This Brooklyn bakery is an award-winning spot that is women-led. It is also known as both a retail and wholesale bakery known for their cakes and cookies and you can even buy them on Goldbelly to have them shipped nationwide!
Ovenly is famous for its Blackout Brooklyn Cake, which you can get delivered or buy directly through the bakery. Many customers love pairing the desserts from Ovenly with a cup of their strong espresso!
Keep in mind that Ovenly only takes payment through card. Furthermore, when you buy the blackout cake, the minimum is two slices for $10!
Must-Try: Brooklyn Blackout Cake! Also, lemon lavender cake or chocolate Amarena cherry cake!
Little Cupcake Bakeshop
598 Vanderbilt Ave, Prospect Heights & 9102 3rd Ave, Bay Ridge
Little Cupcake Bakeshop is a sustainable bakery and cafe that’s great for both breakfast and a late-night treat! This popular pick for best bakery in Brooklyn has two locations in the borough including Prospect Heights and Bay Ridge as well as a location at Prince Street in Manhattan.
This bakery’s cupcakes were voted the best in America by Food & Wine and the Food Network claims this Brooklyn bakery resurrected the Brooklyn Blackout Cake, now that’s a claim!
Some of their most popular flavors include dark chocolate and cookie dough cupcakes plus blue velvet! However, if you’re craving cheesecake or a croissant, you can find that here too!
Little Cupcake Bakeshop is a great place to shop if you’re looking for a larger dessert or custom cake for a big event. Their large selection of desserts also go great with their famous hot chocolate!
Must-Try: Brooklyn Blackout Cake!
Caputo’s Bake Shop
View this post on Instagram
329 Court St, Carroll Gardens
Caputo’s Bake Shop is a well-known Sicilian bakery in Brooklyn in the Carroll Gardens neighborhood that has been passed down for five generations of the same family making it one of the best neighborhood establishments that’s OG.
Everything that Caputo’s has to offer is authentic, fresh, and affordable! Guests love their fresh loaves of bread and Italian cookies.
This old-school Italian bakery in Brooklyn is a great place to visit if you’re craving some of those famous Italian cookies, lobster tails, cannoli, eclairs, cream puffs, and sfogliatella to give you an idea of the classic Italian treats they offer.
They also carry that famous lard bread, so you can compare between Mazzola’s and Caputo’s which are just a few blocks from one another and decide for yourself who did it better.
Keep in mind that Caputo’s Bake Shop does not take credit cards.
Must-Try: Fresh baked Scillian loaf and lard bread
Patisserie Tomoko
View this post on Instagram
568 Union Ave, Williamsburg
Patisserie Tomoko is a creative pastry shop in Williamsburg that serves Japanese-influenced French treats, wine, and coffee! All deserts at this best bakery in Brooklyn take inspiration from both European and Japanese cuisine, making this fusion unique to any other of the bakeries in Brooklyn mentioned!
Since 2012 when it opened, Brooklyn locals and guests have loved Patisserie Tomoko’s pre-fixe dessert as well as their signature mochi and macaroon flavors. Their mille crepes are heavenly and their cakes are also stunning and perfect to custom order for any special occasion.
If you’re searching for a dessert bar with an all-you-can-eat feel, this is the perfect place for you!
Must-Try: Earl Grey chocolate mochi, green tea mochi, and green tea mille crepe
Pasticceria Monteleone
View this post on Instagram
355 Court Street, Carroll Gardens
Pasticceria Monteleone is a traditional Sicilian bakeshop located in Carroll Gardens and is one of the top picks for best bakery in Brooklyn if you’re looking to go traditional Italian.
This Pasticceria was opened in 2011 by Antionio Fiorentino and his wife who came to NYC from Sicily in 1977. Now, this bakeshop is most known for its Italian cake, cookies, gelato, and cannoli! They also offer traditional desserts and custom cakes that are great for any event.
Whether you’re looking for a rainbow cookie or an Italian cake, Pasticceria Monteleone is sure to have what you’re looking for plus an authentic, Sicilian feel.
They also have an Italian pantry available to shop from to get hard-to-find Italian grocery items to take home to your kitchen.
Must-Try: cannoli and chocolate eclair
Napoli Bakery
View this post on Instagram
616 Metropolitan Ave, Williamsburg
Napoli Bakery is a family-run bakery in Brooklyn located on Metropolitan Avenue in Williamsburg. Napoli Bakery is known for its homemade biscotti, brick-oven loaves of bread including their lard bread, and Italian desserts that are perfect to take home or bring to large events!
Although this is a popular bakery in Brooklyn, this is also a great spot to have a larger breakfast or lunch. Guests love their large Italian sandwiches made with their fresh baked breads!
Must-Try: lard bread
Villabate Alba
7001 18th Ave, Bensonhurst
Looking for one of the most legendary Italian bakeries in Brooklyn passed down from one generation to the next? Villabate Alba in Bensonhurst regularly has lines out the door to get into this famous dessert shop.
This bakery is one of the most popular in Brooklyn and is known for its traditional Sicilian pastries and gelato. Once you’re inside this pasticceria you’ll feel swept away to another world with the walls lined with glass cases filled with sweets and even a Rennassiance style painted ceiling.
From legendary cannolis delicious enough for the likes of Jay Z and Beyonce to custom wedding cakes, this popular bakery has just about every dessert you’ll need. They also sell a ton of their marzipan and gelato!
Must-Try: cake version of their cannoli & cannoli
Court Pastry Shop
View this post on Instagram
298 Court St, Carroll Gardens
This is one of the famous, old-school Brooklyn bakeries that’s been around since 1948 by Sicilian-Brooklynite Salvatore Zerilli, now his sons continue the family tradition and run this best bakery in Brooklyn with the walls adorned with family photos and old newspaper clippings.
They’ve got the legendary lobster tails, or also known as sfagliatelle and often have lines in the summer for people trying to get their hands on one of their Italian ices. They also have the classics like cannolis, 7 layer cookies, macaroons, cakes, and pies to give you an idea of their huge selection.
This is a cash-only establishment.
Must-Try: Italian Ice on a hot day and a lobster tail
Circo’s Pastry Shop
View this post on Instagram
312 Knickerbocker Ave, Bushwick
Another legendary old-school pastry shop and bakery in Brooklyn dating back to 1945 is Circo’s Pastry Shop in Bushwick. Loaded with Italian and French pastries you can find an array of cakes, cookies, and cakes for any of your special occasions.
Don’t miss out on their classics like cannoli, eclair, rainbow cookies, cheesecake, and tiramisu
Must-Try: cannoli, rainbow cookies, cheesecake
Rimini Bakery
View this post on Instagram
6822 Bay Pkwy, Bensonhurst
There’s no shortage of fine Italian food shops and bakeries in Brooklyn in the neighborhood of Bensonhurst and Rimini Bakery is no different. This Scillian Brooklyn bakery has been around since 1973.
You can find cakes and pastries here including everything from all kinds of cannoli to lobster tails, eclair, tiramisu, 7 layer cake, tarts, and all kinds of flavors of mousse not to mention gelato. Speaking of gelato, they even do a gelato cake! Move over ice cream cake!
Also, during the Easter holiday this is where you can get some of the traditional Italian egg bread.
Must-Try: cannoli & gelato
Tasty Pastry Shoppe
8216-18 13th Ave, Dyker Heights
Of the Italian bakeries in Brooklyn, this is one of my favorites probably because its a great stop before or after strolling through the Dyker Heights Christmas Lights and the perfect place to get a holiday cookie or classic Italian dessert from their selection of cakes, cookies, and pastries.
Tasty Pastry Shoppe has many festive treats around basically every holiday of the year and is a great place to get a cake for any special celebratory event. Don’t miss other fun items like their 7 layer cupcake as well as your classics like cannoli.
Must-Try: the festive cookies, 7 layer goodies
[line]
Did we miss any of your picks for best bakeries in Brooklyn? Let us know in the comments below, we are always looking to try and discover new places!
Any list omitting Almondine in Dumbo has no interest for me. Try the Lemon Raspberry Pistachio cake…or whatever catches your eye. Also, the best chocolate cake for my money is at The Chocolate Room on Court St. Very sweet masks poor ingredients and these two show great restraint while using the finest ingredients.
Gotta visit Il Fornaretto on 17th Ave. and 76th street. Excellent Semolina Twist, Olive Bread and Focaccia Barese……..Don’t leave it off the list next time!!
Thanks for the recommendations plus what to try! We will go check that out!
You should include Savarese Italian pastry shoppe which has been in same location since 1918 and Jean Danet pastry shoppe also in same location for over 40 years
Thanks!! We need to go check that out, we love old school institutions like that!
And do not forget Mansoura’s on Kings Highway for Middle Eastern pastries.
Great tip, thankyou for sharing!
Forgot all about ave N mill basin. Best lobster tail(pastry) not all about the bread , enough with cupcakes. Good old school standards that have lasted hundreds of years.